This was originally published in the India File newsletter, which is issued every Tuesday. Sign up here to get the latest news from India and how it matters to the world.

Whether arbitrage or manipulation, the Jane Street episode highlights a critical truth: markets need more transparency, more accountability, and more human judgment.

At the heart of the controversy is a long-running investigation into the firm’s index arbitrage strategy, one that Jane Street insists is standard and legal, but which Sebi believes may have distorted prices in India’s rapidly growing equity derivatives market.